BOWLING GREEN, Ohio — More than 50 artists, writers and film scholars are supporting the immediate restoration of the names of the Gish sisters, Dorothy and Lillian, to the film theater that was established more than 40 years ago at Bowling Green State University. The Gish sisters’ mother, Mary McConnell Gish, was an Urbana native.
“This controversy detracts from the great legacy Gish left us in her extensive and varied career,” the statement said. “For a university to dishonor her by singling out just one film, however offensive it is, is unfortunate and unjust. Doing so makes her a scapegoat in a broader political debate. A university should be a bastion of free speech. This is a supreme ‘teachable moment’ if it can be handled with a more nuanced sense of history.”
Among those signing their names are James Earl Jones, Helen Mirren, Martin Scorsese, Malcolm McDowell and Lauren Hutton.
Their statement reads in part: “Lillian Gish (1893-1993) is one of the greatest artists ever to grace the motion picture screen. So we were disappointed to learn that Bowling Green State University in Ohio has decided to strip Miss Gish’s name — and that of her sister, Dorothy, another prominent actress and fellow Ohio native — from its Gish Film Theater and Gallery.”
In May, the BGSU Board of Trustees passed a resolution renaming the theater, citing Lillian Gish’s connection to the film “The Birth of a Nation” and its “negative and hostile impact on society.”
Mike Kaplan, who produced Gish’s “The Whales of August,” led the resulting petition effort to restore the Gish name.
“What should happen because of this is this should be a teachable moment. There should be a symposium, where lots of scholars should come in, where they talk about the period, about the film business, about the film industry and about how it affected people, and all of her movies should be shown, so people would know what she was about,” Kaplan said in a phone interview.
Kaplan worked for MGM and met Gish during the making of “The Comedians.” He is listed on the Gish Film Theater and Gallery National Advisory Committee and said he was not consulted by the BGSU task force on the name change.
Kaplan said that other members have asked for the return of donations, but he is not going to do so, as he believes they should be studied both in general and in relation to this issue.
“I really hope that this opens up a dialogue. That’s more important than this individual issue because people jump on bandwagons and make instant knee jerk responses and things without exploring the ambiguity of history and what things mean. I really hope something more comes from this,” Kaplan said.
He is hoping “something can happen” when the BGSU trustees next meet on June 27.
The university, however, in a statement released Tuesday, said the decision to take the Gish name off the theater would stay.
“Bowling Green State University has a primary responsibility to serve its students, faculty, and staff, and an obligation to create an inclusive learning environment. That obligation outweighs the University’s small part in honoring the Gish sisters’ legacy.
“The decision to remove the Gish name from the relocated film theater was made with the values and best interests of our community in mind, and we stand by it.”
The statement said that the decision was made following extensive input from students, faculty, staff, alumni and members of the public.
“We understood that, whatever the decision, some would be unhappy. However, we are proud of the way our community dealt with this issue – coming together to have a respectful dialogue. We believe that is what strong learning communities do.
“The artistry and accomplishments of the Gish sisters are not lost on the University. The honorary degree the University awarded Lilian Gish, the scholarship in her name, and our archival collections of Gish memorabilia remain in place,” the BGSU statement concluded.
Ralph Wolfe, distinguished professor emeritus of English and Gish Professor of Film Studies, said he welcomed the attention of the artists and actors.
“I’m pleased to know that this is getting national coverage and what has happened at Bowling Green State University,” he said. “I’d be happy to see it (the Gish name) restored.”
The statement by the actors and artists was released on Tuesday. It’s titled “Lillian Gish: An Opportunity for Fairness and Justice.”
“Gish was a warm and caring human being who worked tirelessly to champion the causes of film preservation and film as a medium to promote universal harmony,” the statement said.
Wolfe agreed, citing the prestigious Dorothy & Lillian Gish Prize that she established through her will in 1994. It is for “a man or woman who has made an outstanding contribution to the beauty of the world and to mankind’s enjoyment and understanding of life.”
“She was a really very genuine person and it’s one of the biggest prizes in the country,” Wolfe said.
Recipients have included Bob Dylan, Frank Gehry, Pete Seeger, Maya Lin, Laurie Anderson, Chile’s Isabel Allende, Nigerian author-diplomat Chinua Achebe, and African-American artists Spike Lee, Ornette Coleman, Bill T. Jones, Anna Deavere Smith, Lloyd Richards and Suzan-Lori Parks.
When Lee accepted the Gish Prize in 2013, he said, “Would you believe, two of the most important films that impacted me while I was studying at NYU starred Miss Lillian Gish. Those films were D. W. Griffith’s ‘The Birth of a Nation’ and Charles Laughton’s ‘The Night of the Hunter.’ Isn’t it funny (sometimes) how life works? And how ironic life can be? God can be a trickster. Peace and love to the Gish Sisters. …”
The BGSU Trustees’ resolution passed in May stated that upon reviewing the totality of Lillian Gish’s acting career, no evidence was found that she denounced or distanced herself from Griffith or her link from “The Birth of a Nation.”
BGSU has a primary responsibility to its students, family and staff and an obligation to create an inclusive learning environment, the trustees’ resolution stated.
“The artistry and accomplishments of both Gish sisters throughout their careers was not lost on the task force, which recognized that other honors bestowed on Lillian Gish by BGSU, including an honorary degree, a scholarship in her name and the archival collections, should remain unchanged.”
The Task Force on the Gish Film Theater recommended the removal of the Gish name in its April 17 report to President Rodney Rogers.
The Black Student Union showed Ava DuVernay’s film “13th” as part of Black History Month celebrations. In that film, clips from the 1915 D.W. Griffith movie “The Birth of a Nation” were used as part of discussions of racism in America.
The report stated, on Feb. 10, the “BSU noted the irony of showing ‘13th’ in a theater named for the star of ‘The Birth of a Nation’ and brought to the university’s attention the problematic nature of the Gish name for BGSU’s African American students.”
The task force was formed as a result of the BSU request for a change to the theater name. It was led by Raymond Craig, dean of the College of Arts and Sciences, and included 11 others representing faculty, administrative staff and students, meeting over a period of six weeks.
For more than 40 years, the theater was located in Hanna Hall. In 2017, the decision was made to move the theater to the Bowen-Thompson Student Union.